Negotiating Under Pressure

Why Do We Struggle to Speak Up When It Matters Most?

What the poker table can teach us about confidence, negotiation and making better decisions under pressure.

Have you ever walked away from a meeting knowing you should have said something, but didn't? Perhaps you had a different perspective, spotted a risk or knew that your idea could have changed the direction of the conversation.

But something stopped you.

Or perhaps you've experienced the opposite. You've gone into a difficult conversation determined to make your point, only to realise afterwards that you were so focused on being heard that you missed what everyone else was saying.

It's interesting how differently we can behave when the stakes feel high. And it's not always about how confident or capable we are. Sometimes, it's about what happens to us under pressure.

I recently explored this with Jo Living, Founder of Aces High, on my Leaders Who Coach™ podcast. Jo is a former investment banker and entrepreneur who uses poker as an experiential learning tool to help people develop negotiation, decision-making and communication skills.

Now, you might wonder what playing poker has to do with leadership. Quite a lot, as it turns out. Because the poker table has a rather interesting way of revealing how we behave when we're uncertain, uncomfortable or feel we have something to lose. And often, those are exactly the behaviours we're bringing into our workplace conversations.

Why do we behave differently when we're under pressure?

One of the things Jo explained was how quickly a simple game of poker can bring out our natural stress responses. Even when there's no real money involved, people become nervous. Their breathing changes. Their hands shake. Some become unusually quiet, while others start making increasingly aggressive moves.

And what's fascinating is how closely those behaviours mirror what happens in meetings, negotiations and other high-stakes conversations.

Some of us fight. We become more assertive, push harder and focus on getting our point across. Some of us withdraw. We hold back, avoid the difficult conversation or decide it's safer not to challenge what's being said. And others freeze. We keep asking for more information, delay making a decision or become so caught up in the possibilities that we struggle to move forward.

Jo described these responses through the language of poker: raise, fold or call. But I think it's worth considering how these patterns show up in our leadership. When you're under pressure, do you tend to push harder, pull back or avoid making a decision? Because recognising that pattern is the beginning of being able to choose something different.

Are you folding when you should be playing your hand?

One of Jo's observations from her workshops particularly caught my attention. She noticed that some women, even when they held a strong hand, were reluctant to bet confidently. Rather than asking what move would give them the best opportunity to win, they were asking what the minimum bet was.

And there's an interesting parallel here with the workplace. How often do capable people underestimate the value of what they bring? They might have a good idea but hesitate to share it. They might be ready for a promotion but wait to be noticed. Or they might enter a negotiation already prepared to accept less than they could reasonably ask for.

Jo shared an example of a participant who was dealt the strongest possible starting hand in poker, a pair of aces. But when other players raised the stakes, she became so uncomfortable that she folded before the game had really begun. She knew she had a strong hand.
Yet the pressure of the situation caused her to walk away from the opportunity. I think many of us can recognise something of ourselves in that.

Not necessarily at a poker table, but in those moments when we allow uncertainty or discomfort to determine our next move.
And I wonder how often leaders unintentionally reinforce this behaviour in their teams. If the loudest person is always heard, or if challenging a decision feels risky, people may learn that staying quiet is the safer option. Which means valuable perspectives never make it into the conversation.

So perhaps a useful question for leaders is: Who might have something important to contribute but doesn't feel confident enough to say it? And what could you do differently to help them?

What if you're the person who always speaks first?

Of course, the opposite can be just as problematic. Jo described another type of player. Someone who responds to pressure by becoming more aggressive.

They might have a reasonably strong hand, but they're so focused on winning that they stop paying attention to what everyone else is doing. They become more committed to their own position, even when new information suggests they should reconsider. And that reminded me of something I see quite often in leadership conversations.

Someone senior enters a meeting with a strong opinion. They share it early, perhaps with the best of intentions. And before long, everyone else is agreeing. But agreement doesn't necessarily mean alignment. Sometimes people agree because they genuinely support the decision. Sometimes they agree because they don't want to challenge the most senior person in the room. And sometimes they simply haven't had enough space to think.

Jo introduced the idea of the highest-paid person's opinion, often called the HIPPO. When the most senior person speaks first, their view can influence everything that follows. Which is why, in some conversations, one of the most useful things a leader can do is speak last. Not because their perspective doesn't matter. But because everyone else's perspective matters too.

And if we want to make well-informed decisions, we need access to information that might otherwise remain unspoken. It's a simple change, but one that can make quite a difference.

Is negotiation really about winning?

I think negotiation is one of those words that makes people uncomfortable. We often associate it with confrontation, persuasion or having to outmanoeuvre someone.

There's an assumption that someone has to win and someone else has to lose. But most workplace negotiations are rarely that straightforward. We're negotiating with colleagues, clients, stakeholders and our own teams. And often, we're all trying to achieve something broadly similar, even though we're approaching it from very different perspectives. Marketing might want to invest more. Finance might be concerned about cost. Operations might be questioning whether the organisation can deliver what's being promised. Nobody necessarily wants a bad outcome. They're simply looking at the situation through different lenses.

Jo made an important point about this. In poker, you don't need to win every hand to win the tournament. And perhaps that's a useful way to think about negotiation. Sometimes the most strategic decision is to let something go. Sometimes it's to stand firm. And sometimes it's to understand what matters to the other person before deciding what you're prepared to offer.

That requires us to move away from thinking only about what we want. And towards understanding what the other person needs.

What are they trying to achieve?

What might they be concerned about?

Where do they have flexibility, and where don't they?

These are coaching questions as much as they are negotiation questions. Because when we become more curious about another person's perspective, we often discover possibilities that weren't obvious at the beginning.

How do we make better decisions when we don't have all the information?

There's another part of poker that I find particularly relevant to leadership. You're constantly making decisions without knowing everything. You can see your own cards and some of what's happening around the table. But you can't know exactly what everyone else is holding. And sometimes, you have to decide anyway.

That sounds rather familiar, doesn't it?

Leaders are regularly expected to make decisions with incomplete information. There's a deadline approaching. A client needs an answer. A team is waiting for direction. And although we'd like more certainty, we don't always have the luxury of waiting for it.

Jo spoke about evaluating risk in terms of the potential reward rather than simply trying to eliminate it. In other words, the question isn't always whether we can guarantee a successful outcome. It's whether the opportunity is worth pursuing, given what we know. And I think this is where leaders can help their teams develop more confidence in their own decision-making.

Rather than immediately providing an answer, we can ask:

What do we know so far?

What's the risk if we proceed?

What's the risk if we do nothing?

What would make this a reasonable decision, even if the outcome isn't guaranteed?

We're not removing uncertainty. We're helping people learn how to think and act more effectively within it. And that's quite a different capability.

What can we do when our emotions start making the decisions? One of the most valuable parts of my conversation with Jo was around emotional regulation. Because knowing what we should do and actually being able to do it under pressure are not always the same thing.

We can understand the importance of listening. We can know that we need to consider other perspectives. We can even recognise that we're becoming defensive or anxious. But in the moment, our stress response can still take over.

Jo explained how she helps people notice the physical signs of stress during her workshops.

Some hold their breath.
Some become restless.
Others rush into decisions or withdraw altogether.

And by noticing what's happening, they begin to develop more choice over how they respond. I think that's an important part of developing ourselves as leaders. We can't always control the pressure we're under, but we can become more aware of how it's affecting our behaviour. Sometimes that means slowing down. Taking a moment before responding. Asking another question rather than immediately defending our position. Or simply recognising that we're not in the best state to make an important decision. Small changes, perhaps.

But they can significantly change the direction of a conversation.

What can we do when our emotions start making the decisions?

One of the most valuable parts of my conversation with Jo was around emotional regulation. Because knowing what we should do and actually being able to do it under pressure are not always the same thing.

We can understand the importance of listening.
We can know that we need to consider other perspectives.
We can even recognise that we're becoming defensive or anxious.

But in the moment, our stress response can still take over. Jo explained how she helps people notice the physical signs of stress during her workshops.

Some hold their breath.
Some become restless.
Others rush into decisions or withdraw altogether.

And by noticing what's happening, they begin to develop more choice over how they respond. I think that's an important part of developing ourselves as leaders. We can't always control the pressure we're under, but we can become more aware of how it's affecting our behaviour. Sometimes that means slowing down. Taking a moment before responding.

Asking another question rather than immediately defending our position. Or simply recognising that we're not in the best state to make an important decision. Small changes, perhaps.

But they can significantly change the direction of a conversation.

How can leaders help people practise being more confident?

One of the things I particularly enjoyed about Jo's approach is that she doesn't simply teach people about negotiation. She puts them in situations where they experience it.

At the poker table, people get to observe their behaviours, make decisions, see the consequences and try something different. And they do this in a setting where the stakes are deliberately kept low. That immediate feedback is powerful. Because confidence doesn't necessarily come from someone telling us we should be more confident.

It often comes from having enough experiences of trying, learning and discovering that we're more capable than we thought. I think there's an opportunity for leaders to bring more of this into everyday work. Give someone the opportunity to lead a conversation they might usually avoid. Encourage them to present a recommendation rather than simply report information.Help them prepare for a difficult discussion, then reflect afterwards on what happened. Not just whether they achieved the outcome they wanted.

But what they noticed about themselves. What worked. What they might do differently next time. This is where coaching can become part of the way we lead, rather than something reserved for a formal coaching session. We're helping people develop their own awareness, judgement and confidence through experience.

Perhaps the real question is how we're showing up.

As I reflected on my conversation with Jo through my Leaders Who Coach™ lens, three things stood out. The first is emotional regulation. When we're better able to manage our own responses, we're more likely to notice what's happening around us. We can listen more carefully, recognise tension and respond with greater awareness rather than simply reacting.

The second is asking better questions and listening more deeply. We rarely have all the information we need at the beginning of a difficult conversation. But by being curious and making room for other perspectives, we can develop a much clearer picture before deciding what to do.

And the third is learning through experience.

We can talk about confidence, negotiation and decision-making for hours. But there's something very different about putting ourselves in situations where we have to practise those capabilities.

To notice our default responses. To try something different. And to discover what happens.

Jo's poker table provides a rather clever way of making those behaviours visible. But we don't necessarily need a deck of cards to begin developing them. We have opportunities in our conversations every day. The meeting where we could listen a little longer. The negotiation where we could become more curious about the other person's position. The moment when someone needs encouragement to speak up. Or the decision where we need to recognise that waiting for complete certainty may be holding us back.

Because perhaps being a more effective leader isn't about always making the strongest move. It's about becoming more aware of when to speak, when to listen, when to take a risk and when to step aside.

So here's a question I'd encourage you to reflect on.

When the pressure is on, are you responding to what's actually happening, or are you simply playing the hand you've always played?